Sunday, November 11, 2012

Scott, Elaine. Buried Alive.


Scott, Elaine.    Buried Alive.     Houghton Mifflin/Clarion      80p   $17.99  978-0-547-70778-5     elem        E-BN       

The disastrous Chilean mine collapse of 2010 is presented for young readers in grades 3-6, with all the anxious moments of both trapped miners and relatives presented to readers in an appropriate way.  Teamwork and hope were the two words associated with the rescue.  Throughout the book, which is filled with excellent color photos of trapped miners, distraught relatives, and workers trying to devise a rescue plan, the author conveys a sense of urgency to the reader.  Teamwork is the principal that allowed the trapped miners to survive in darkness for seventeen days without knowing if they would be rescued.  Teamwork is what people above ground exhibited as they sought the means for a successful rescue. Relatives and friends of the miners also banded together to maintain a vigil through the over-two-month rescue process.  Hope was the emotion that filled miners, relatives, and rescuers, as they never gave up on their belief that the miners could be rescued.  The author does an outstanding job of presenting the lifestyle of the trapped miners, the steadfastness of relatives in the camp outside the mine, and the international efforts to provide equipment and ideas for rescuing the miners.  This book is to be commended for the author’s statement on how she researched her book and the afterword that relays the current status of the miners, which in many cases is far from the glory of the first month after rescue.  An extraordinary book for students who want to learn about the value of helping others through difficult times.  In short, this is an outstanding account of the Chilean mine disaster with excellent documentation and photographs for young readers that shows how hope and teamwork can lead to a positive outcome.                                  -- Lois McNicol

No comments: