Morrison, Megan. Disenchanted: Trials of Cinderella.
Scholastic/Arthur Levine 2016 404p $17.99 ISBN 978-0-545-64271-2 Hardback ms/jr Fantasy
E-BN
A retelling, sort of, of the Cinderella story. Ella is
fed up with the superficiality of her wealthy friends and really wants to
reform society. Dash (Prince Charming) has broken the Curse that held his
family in a web of lying, cheating and flattery. He wants to be a better person
but has so much trouble expressing himself without the glib voice of the Curse.
The third major player in the story is Serge, a blue fairy godfather. He really
would prefer to be helping needy children rather than catering to the whims of
the wealthy.
These three characters work together to make a difference
in their world. They start in the garment workhouses where young children work
in horrible conditions. Ella knows of these conditions from firsthand
experience, because she and her mother worked there before her mother died and
her father remarried a wealthy woman.
This is an almost complete departure from the classic Cinderella story. Even the stepsisters become a stepsister and a stepbrother who belong to a band that plays at the Prince’s ball. They also are nice to Ella. Her Stepmother isn’t evil but a self-assured wealthy businesswoman who really wants to do right by Ella. Ella is the one who rejects everyone’s overtures and festers in the sorrow of her mother’s death.
The conditions in the garment workhouses are reminiscent
of conditions that existed in the past. The fire that Ella is accused of
starting draws authenticity from the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire. These
connections add depth and veracity to the story.
Witty dialog, bits of magic, and interesting characters
enliven this title. A previous adventure in the land of Tyme involved Rapunzel.
The assumption is that other adventures are waiting to be written. It would be
a great read for grades 4-8. The changes to the Cinderella story actually make
it more believable.
Summary: A retelling of the Cinderella story, sort of.
Much has been changed, but the reader will recognize the basic story. Witty
dialog, magic, and action enliven this tale. Great read for grades 4-8.
Cinderella-Fiction, Magic-Fiction —Joan Theal
No comments:
Post a Comment